[4] The new version reached number one on the Billboard Country Digital Song Sales chart in the United States.

Saiid Zeidan of Medium favourably reviewed "To Be a Man", stating that the "raw vulnerability and intricate storytelling" of the song left him "in awe".

[7] Alex Harris of Neon Music described "To Be a Man" as "raw, emotional, and introspective," adding that Dax's "lyrical prowess shines as he grapples with societal expectations and the true essence of manhood".

[9] Osafo Daniel of Ghana Plug said that the song "provides a powerful platform for exploring these complexities, ultimately encouraging dialogue about the emotional well-being of men".

[11][12] The official video for the version of the song featuring Darius Rucker premiered on October 27, 2023, and was also directed by Logan Meis.