In 1977, Reynolds signed with the Dallas Tornado of the North American Soccer League.
Moving to the Los Angeles Aztecs for the 1978-1979 NASL Indoor season, he was released without having played any games.
He then signed with the California Sunshine of the American Soccer League.
[1] He spent the 1980 season with the Sacramento Gold, ranking only behind Scott Manning in GAA.
[2] Reynolds spent 1980 & 1981 with the Major Indoor Soccer League as a Keeper for the San Francisco Fog.