[2][3] Born and raised in Cincinnati, Ohio, Huster attended Saint Ursula Academy and helped lead the team to the 2007 High School State Championship with a game-winning goal in the finals.

Throughout her collegiate career, Huster scored 20 goals and served 19 assists in her 92 appearances with the Seminoles.

[4][7] In the fall of 2009 Tori received the Golden Torch Award, which is given to the athlete from each sport with the highest grade point average.

Out of Florida State University Huster was selected in the second round (8th overall) by the Western New York Flash in the 2012 WPS Draft.

[8] Huster was the second pick (seventh overall) by the Washington Spirit during the 2013 NWSL Supplemental Draft in preparation for the inaugural season of the National Women's Soccer League.

The midfielder scored her lone goal of the season on July 2 at home in a 2–0 win against FC Kansas City.

[13] In September 2014 Huster joined Newcastle Jets together with fellow Americans Katherine Reynolds and Angela Salem.

[15] In October 2017, Huster returned to Australia for the off-season, joining Newcastle Jets for the 2017–18 W-League season alongside fellow Americans Katie Stengel, Arin Wright and Britt Eckerstrom.