In 1932, they defeated Philadelphia’s Fairhill club 4-0 in the first round but lost 2-0 to the Newark Americans.
[1] In 1937, the Highlanders won the eastern National Amateur Cup, defeating the Brooklyn Germans 2-1 after two periods of extra time.
[2] They won the National Amateur Cup final by defeated Pittsburgh Castle Shannon 1-0.
[4][5] The Highlanders were defeated 9-1 by Argentina led by Ángel Laferrara (who scored 5 goals) in the opening match.
[6][5] The Highlanders then lost 3-2 to Canada (represented by the Irish Soccer Club from Winnipeg).