Fryfogle grew up in Lucedale, Mississippi and attended George County High School.
[2] Fryfogle committed to play college football at Indiana over Ole Miss and Idaho.
[3][4] Despite initially considering redshirting, Fryfogle played in eight games as a true freshman, catching one pass for 13 yards.
[8] He was named the Big Ten Conference Offensive Player of the Week on November 14, 2020, after catching 11 passes for 200 yards and two touchdowns against Michigan State.
[18] On August 30, 2024, Fryfogle signed with the San Antonio Brahmas of the United Football League (UFL).