The Festival was subsequently canceled in 2022 due to "multiple disruptions related to the rapid community spread of the Omicron variant".

[3] Under the Radar was almost immediately revived [4] in collaboration with the NYC production company ArKtype.

The 2024 iteration of the Festival ran from January 5 to January 21, presenting more than 180 performances of 17 distinct productions at 11 different theaters across Brooklyn and Manhattan, including Brooklyn Academy of Music, Lincoln Center, Theatre for a New Audience, La MaMa Experimental Theatre Club, Japan Society (Manhattan), the Abrons Arts Center at Henry Street Settlement, BRIC Arts Media, New York Live Arts, Skirball Center for the Performing Arts, St. Ann's Warehouse, Mabou Mines, and The Invisible Dog Art Center.

Additional programming as part of the 2024 Festival included a Symposium featuring keynote conversations with Jeremy O. Harris, Ravi Jain, Hana Sharif, and Kaneza Schall; a "Coming Attractions" artistic pitch session; a six show "UFO" works-in-progress performance calendar; and an "Anti-Misogynoir Disco" dance party at Lincoln Center spotlighting local Black women DJs, including Erica "Twelve45" Blunt, DJ Shannon, Lady NiK and Miss Hap.

The 2024 season was a critical and commercial success, selling out the vast majority of its performances.