Awarding the album four stars at CCM Magazine, Grace Aspinwall states, "Unstoppable Love is filled with passionate, soaring vocals".

"[2] Giving the album four and a half stars from New Release Today, Kevin Davis describes being, "impressed by the consistent quality and fresh worshipful songs that come from Jesus Culture.

"[8] Stephen Luff, indicating in a nine out of ten review by Cross Rhythms, says, "The album delivers a set of worship songs of the highest quality and leaders Chris Quilala and Kim Walker-Smith have clearly lost none of their prophetic power.

"[5] Jono Davies, specifying in a four and a half star review from Louder Than the Music, declares, "Jesus Culture have put together a stunning collection of songs of worship to the King of Kings whose love never stops.

"[7] Assigning the album an eight and a half star review for Jesus Wired, Jessica Morris recognizes, "Unstoppable Love is a bold and riveting release by Jesus Culture.