[5] Paul Lester of The Guardian noted that the extended play balances a dreamlike quality with themes of desire and infatuation, moving beyond surface-level sentiments to explore possession and obsession.

[5] "Fantasy", described by Lester as reminiscent of a slowed-down Mariah Carey track, explores escapism and emotional liberation, with Baraz cooing about a place free of time and space.

[5] "Maybe" addresses the duality of deceit and devotion, with Lester noting Baraz's playful vocal lilt and Edwin Ortiz of Complex pointing out the track's forbidden love narrative.

[5] The closing track, "Unfold", inspired by a time-lapse video of a blooming flower, encapsulates themes of emotional growth and transformation with Baraz's airy delivery and Galimatias' subtle instrumental backdrop.

Andy Kellman of AllMusic called the album "consistently relaxed and slightly trippy, nearly torpid, filled with lapping sounds carefully plotted for solitary and one-on-one bedroom settings.

"[3] Complex's Edwin Ortiz praised the EP, saying, "Alina's sensual vocals and Galimatias' equally ravishing backdrops are a perfect marriage on Urban Flora, which effectively sounds and feels like a dedication to the one in your life.