[4] The club won its first major honors in 2014, when it had a perfect season, winning all eight of their games and taking the 2014 FFAS Senior League championship.

Conrado Kaleopa and Iotamo Lameta were the goalscorers in the final game of the season, a 2–1 victory over Lion Heart, which would finish second in the league.

[1] Utulei Youth also won American Samoa's annual knockout tournament, the FFAS President's Cup, again with a 2–1 victory over Lion Heart.

[2] The Utulei Youth women's team also won in the national league in 2014, and came in second in the President's Cup, behind PanSa.

Note: Flags indicate national team as defined under FIFA eligibility rules; some limited exceptions apply.