[1] In the 1911–12 season, the team made its first appearance in the playoffs of the Baltenverband where they were convincingly put out (0:7) in a quarterfinal match versus BuEV Danzig.

They beat VfB Königsberg to finish second overall in the Baltenverband and move on to a national level eighth-final match up against Tennis Borussia Berlin where they lost 0:3.

However, they were unable to translate those victories into success on the national stage, failing to advance out of opening round group play in the German championship.

The team also took part in play for the Tschammerpokal, predecessor to today's DFB-Pokal (German Cup), in 1936, 1939, and 1941, being put out in the second round in each appearance.

Stolp continued to field strong sides in the early 1940s, but were only able to capture the Gauliga Pommern-Ost group title once more in 1942 before losing the overall division final 1:6 to Luftwaffe Sport-Verein Pütnitz.