[13] Walter failed to gain selection for the Lower Waikato representative side to play the touring Marist Old Boys club from Auckland on August 29, with George in the backs and William a forward reserve.

They won by 11 points to 0 and Tittleton was chosen in the South Auckland side for the match against Eastern Suburbs to be played at Steele Park in Hamilton on October 14.

Wally was involved in a try after he and R. Garry combined "together in a dashing passing move down inside touch" before his brother George "rushed up to be the extra man and he went over the line in a flash well out".

[46] South Auckland won easily at Ngāruawāhia by 31 points to 6 with Wally involved in a try to H. Hill after combining with his brother George and Huatahi Paki.

The Auckland Star wrote that "W. Tittleton, the Waikato man, has been playing consistently throughout the season, and can be relied on to give a good account of himself at centre".

The Auckland Star wrote that the side would feature a "smart three quarter line, with Alf Mitchell on one flank and George Tittleton on the other.

[88] In 1936 both Wally and George moved north to Auckland where they joined the Richmond Rovers rugby league club based in Grey Lynn.

[89] The Auckland Star wrote that "George Tittleton, who is to be given the responsibility of full back, and his brother Walter, a fine young five eighth, who will be associated with Eric Fletcher and Roy Powell behind the scrum.

[94] Mt Albert won 22–15, with the Auckland Star writing that both brothers "gave a good account of themselves" with Wally showing "pace and enterprise in the five eighth berth".

[138] In the second half Tittleton made a bad mistake when he threw an intercept which allowed [Barney] Hudson to race away and score, putting "the result beyond doubt".

Bert Cooke had returned to the Richmond side and he along with Ted Mincham and Tittleton stood out and "were in form" playing a "solid game" at five-eighths.

[153] The Herald said that "on his present form W. Tittleton is one of the best five eighths in the code and he played a great all-round game for Richmond against North Shore last Saturday.

[166][167] In an upset loss to Ponsonby 10–9, it was only the "quick covering defence by the nippy Richmond backs, and W. Tittleton and Mincham in particular, that prevented the opposition from scoring".

[175] The match was drawn 11–11 and "Tittleton was right on his game and in addition to showing fine appreciation of his supports defended wonderfully when his side was in dire straits".

[177] The New Zealand Herald suggested that Australian five-eighths Ernie Norman and Percy Williams, are high class wet day players... [and that] Bickerton and Tittleton are set a difficult task to check this pair, and sound defence is essential".

[182] On the Thursday night Tittleton attended a ball arranged for both sides by the Auckland Rugby League ladies’ committee at the Peter Pan Cabaret venue on Queen Street.

[187] The Herald reported that Tittleton "was the best of the three-quarter line, his tackling being an outstanding feature and an object lesson to his fellow-players who were prone to attempt the high collaring so futile against the heavy Australian forwards".

[192] Tittleton scored another try in Richmond's 21–13 loss to City in the first round of the Roope Rooster knockout competition on September 4, however it was to be his last game of the year as he had to leave the field with a broken collarbone.

On October 6 at the Auckland Rugby League meeting it was announced that a special trophy for the season's outstanding senior grade player had been awarded to Wally Tittleton.

The Referee newspaper in Sydney said that "Smith and Tittleto, quick as cats, turned errors by home backs into tries by very clever football, the second try after perfect running and passing, with the supports most timely".

The Courier Mail wrote prior to the third tour match that "the Kiwis possess two grand centres in W. Tittleton (Auckland) and R. Chase, the 20-year-old Māori.

It was suggested in The Telegraph after the match that "Tittleton, … is regarded as one of the most solid defensive players in the side, and he probably will play opposite [Jack] Reardon in an endeavour to curb the man whom the Kiwis consider to be the pivot on which the Queensland attack swings.

In a wordy article on the match in the Truth (Brisbane) newspaper which criticised both teams rather heavily it said some of the New Zealand forward played well, as did Grotte at halfback and "Tittleton, at five eight, was a link without a defensive kink.

Tittleton too full marks on the day for a grand piece of work in defence, even if he did lack the penetrative ability of five eighths we have known in Hay, and Norman".

[241] For Richmond against City Rovers on August 20 in their final round match Tittleton scored a try in their 24–10 win and played a sound game at centre and was hard to stop.

[261] He scored once more against North Shore on June 24 with the Herald writing that he was "fast regaining his best form" but "spoiled an otherwise good display by hanging on too long" in their 9–8 loss.

[286] In a 22–6 win over Manukau in round 13 he was "at the top of his form", giving "an exceptionally sound display… the Auckland and New Zealand representative played a great pivotal game and always improved the position in attack and revealed strong defensive powers.

[324] Richmond were now dropped into the Phelan Shield knockout competition after their Roope Rooster defeat and beat Ōtāhuhu Rovers 18–14 with Tittleton scoring one of their four tries.

[336] So impressive was Tittleton in his first season of rugby union that he was then selected by Fred Lucas as a reserve for the Auckland team to play against an Army side in early August.

[340] The Herald said he and Riley "made good openings for their supports" and "Tittleton paved the way for the first try with a strong straight dash in which he broke past three opponents".