During the club's heyday in the 1920s and 1930s, Waterlows won the Bedfordshire Senior Cup ten times, but only once did they progress to the 1st round proper of the FA Amateur Cup, when in 1937/38 they were narrowly defeated 3–2 by Kingstonian of the Isthmian League.
In 1946, Waterlows rejoined the South Midlands League, winning promotion to the Premier Division in 1956.
In 1985, Waterlows left the South Midlands League for the final time.
[3] Wilson, Mike (2002) The Spartan Football League Volume 2 1930/31 to 1949/50.
This article about a defunct English football club is a stub.