[1][2] It was first published in the United States in print, ebook, and audiobook formats by Quirk Books on September 18, 2018.

The novel centers upon a metal guitarist who discovers that her soul was sold by a former bandmate in order to achieve success.

She wasn't always like this, as back in the nineties she was a guitarist for the heavy metal band Dürt Würk.

[5] We Sold Our Souls was reviewed by SFX, which wrote that it "doesn't have the flair and originality of Hendrix's ingenious Horrorstör, nor the sweetness and emotion of My Best Friend's Exorcism, but it's still a compelling romp with a great central character that'll be a treat for music obsessives of all kinds.

"[6] It was also reviewed by Dread Central and Tor.com,[7] the former of which felt that it was "not just a smart, new look at the trope of the devil (or entities and soul stealing) in regards to music, fame, and fortune, but an indictment on modern society, and how we lose little pieces of ourselves here, there, and everywhere, each day to distractions, materialism, and want of power.