The album contains guest appearances from the Weeknd, Chris Brown, Brownstone, Ty Dolla Sign, J. Cole, Lil Baby, and ASAP Rocky.

Production was primarily handled by Metro himself, with help from Mike Dean, Wheezy, Dre Moon, Southside, Chopsquad DJ, Allen Ritter, Oz, Honorable C.N.O.T.E., and others.

[4] On April 4, Future and Metro formally revealed the second album's title and release date through a trailer, showing the duo in white suits.

[12] Musically, We Still Don't Trust You is noted for expanding out of the duo's "customary hip-hop and trap" genres,[13] in favor of a trap-influenced R&B sound.

Murray noted that although there were several memorable tracks, "there's a huge amount [of songs] that simply passes you by" due to a lack of structure and substance.