[8] The club had more success in the Birmingham Senior Cup, reaching the semi-final in the competition's first year of 1876-77, and the final in 1877–78; the club changed its name between the quarter-final and the semi-final in the latter year from Town to Strollers.

[9] In the final, played at Aston Villa's Wellington Road ground in front of 5,000 spectators, Shrewsbury came from 1–0 down at half-time, the equalizer being scored from a Wace corner "cannoning off" Shrewsbury half-back A. T. Ward, and forward J. E. Sprott scoring the winner after Shrewsbury had struck the bar - an early use of the crossbar.

[10] The Strollers protested (unsuccessfully) that Wace was not a genuine resident of Shrewsbury.

[11] The club reached the last six in 1879-80 and the last eight in 1882–83, both times losing heavily to the professional Walsall Swifts F.C.

[15] By 1876 they had changed to maroon and white, which remained the club's colours until its dissolution.