[27] The 1985 softball team finished the season with a 26-0 record after winning the Group III state championship by defeating Collingswood High School in the tournament final by a score of 6-0.

In 2015, the Minutemen defeated Toms River High School South by a score of 4-0 in the Group III title game, winning the first state championship in the program's history.

[37][38][39] Under head coach Richard Attonito (1971–1988), the team won three Colonial Hills Conference titles (1975, 1982, 1983) and matriculated future NFL linebackers Jim Collins and Carl Zander.

The team won the Group II state championship in 2010 with a win against Princeton High School.

[42] The girls' lacrosse team won the Group II state championship in 2007 (defeating Hopewell Valley Central High School in the tournament final), 2008 (vs. Hopewell Valley), and won the Group III title in 2010 (vs. Shawnee High School).

[43] The team won the 2007 Group II state title with a 17–4 win against Hopewell Valley in the championship game.

[44][45] The team won the 2008 Group II title, again defeating Hopewell Valley, this time by a score of 8-7 in the championship game.

[46] In 2010, the team defeated Shawnee High School by a score of 12–6 in the finals to become the Group III state champions.

[47] The girls' volleyball team was runner-up in the state in 2007, falling to Fair Lawn High School in the group final.

[49] The 2019 team won the Group III state title in two seats against Wayne Valley High School.

[50] In 2010, the boys won the Group III state championship with a 44–41 victory over Kingsway Regional, but fell short to University High School in the quarterfinal round of the Tournament of Champions.

[54] Jim Baglin had a record of 685-192 in his 33 years as coach, from 1979 until 2012, including nine Morris County Tournament titles.

[58] The team won the Group II state championship in 1998 and 1999, defeating Sterling High School in the tournament final both years.

[59] The team won the program's first state title in 1998 with a 58-40 win against Sterling in the Group II championship game held at the Thomas Dunn Sports Center in Elizabeth.

[63] and advanced to the Tournament of Champions as the second seed, beating third-seed East Brunswick High School 71-40 in the semifinals before falling to number-one St. John Vianney by a score of 62-53 in the finals to finish the season with a record of 29-2.

[66] In 2007, the girls' soccer team won the North II, Group III state sectional championship with a 2-0 win over Scotch Plains High School in the tournament final.

2009 graduate Emilee Kovolisky placed 4th at the international fencing competition in Barcelona during the summer following her senior year.