In 2012 the Magic fielded a solitary team in the Division 3 competition, finishing runners up in their inaugural season to the UTS Bats.

A late season charge saw them win the Grand Final over local rivals Penrith to claim the club's 2nd premiership.

The Men's division 2 side made amends for the previous season, defeating Camden by 8 points in the Grand Final.

The club will be coached by Jack Schwarze (Seniors), Anthony Hyland (Reserves), John Dimond (Women's) and Daniel Armstrong (19s).

[3] The women's team was again successful in 2020, winning the AFL Sydney Division 2 grand final over St George under the guidance of Aisha Firmer.