The Western New York League permanently folded after the 1890 season.
When the season ended on September 27, 1890, the Canisteo team was in first place with a 6–0 record.
Canisteo was followed by Wellsville (3–3), Hornell (2–4) and the Bath Bathers (1–5) in the final standings.
Aviator Alfred Lawson was a teammate of McGraw on the Wellsville team.
[4][5] The Western New York League permanently folded after the 1890 season.