When We Don't Exist is the debut studio album by American metalcore band Like Moths to Flames.

It is also the last release with another drummer Kevin Rutherford, who performed on two bonus tracks of the deluxe reissue of the album.

rated the album positively calling it: "For someone who is somewhat sceptical about the majority of metalcore that makes its way out of America these days, I would say that this is fairly good.

"[3] KillYourStereo gave the album 30 out of 100 and said: "Like Moths To Flames have offered up a completely generic sounding record without a single attempt at originality, which these days, is just simply unacceptable.

The high-energy, aggressive in your face band they were in the beginning is completely revamped and recharged on this album.