A team from White Hills first entered the Bendigo DFA in 1924, it lost the grand final by 6 points that year.
Seeking a lower form of competition White Hills opted to transfer to the Heathcote District Football League.
In White Hills' early years in HDFL it has had its peak in quality football and its most success in its history.
In 2004 White Hills had finished in second in the HDFL and had looked like it was going to win another premiership after a pretty long Final drought however they fell short to Colbinabbin who had won the flag three times in a row.
Because of the small sized football league rivalries are few and far between and most teams aren't overly aggressive towards another team; however, White Hills's biggest rivals are North Bendigo, Huntly, Heathcote & Colbinabbin.