[3] In 1851 a very large Gothic building, designed by Henry Masters, was constructed just west of the original tabernacle.

The new unified congregation was named United Church Kingswood and continued to worship until it closed in January 2023.

[5] As of 2007, there were plans for the redevelopment of the three listed buildings on the Tabernacle site, namely the two churches and the 18th-century Chapel House.

Besides various proposed memorial facilities, the plan included flats in the Chapel House and the 19th-century building.

After years of disuse and dereliction following a fire in 2000, restoration work began on the tabernacle in 2021 with a view to turning it into a community arts centre following a £682,000 grant from Metro Mayor Dan Norris.