It was originally recorded by American country music artist Joe Nichols on his 2007 album Real Things.

[1] Country music artist Blake Shelton recorded the song for his EP All About Tonight, from which it was released as a single in September 2010.

The song is a ballad in which the narrator wants to know the characteristics his lover's hiding from him (e.g. "Do you paint your toes 'cause you bite your nails?").

"[2] Jim Malec of American Twang gave the song a thumbs-up review, calling it an "intimate rumination on the mystery of a beautiful, graceful woman.

"[1] Gary Graff of Billboard also described the song positively, saying that it "mixes humor and pathos with a sweet melody and a wry attitude.