[2] Poynter worked as a merchant in Eureka, Illinois, for several years until relocating his family to Albion, Nebraska in 1879.

Poynter worked as a rancher and a farmer in Boone County, Nebraska, and became active in politics.

[5] Poynter was nominated again for President pro tempore of the Nebraska Senate in 1892, but he was defeated by Republican George D. Meiklejohn.

[6] During his tenure as governor, railroad regulations were promoted, and legislation was sanctioned that established Lincoln, Nebraska, as the site for the state fair.

When he retired from public life, he remained active in his own business affairs and was also president of the Security Savings and Loan Association.