The Williamsburg Wizards dominated their age group of the Virginia Youth Soccer Association (VYSA) in the 1990s.
The Wizards competed before the advent of the US Soccer Academy system, and therefore, the VYSA State Cup Championship was the undisputed highest honor to be achieved each year in the commonwealth.
His play earned him a youth national team call-up at the U-16 level, traveling to an international tournament in Montaigu, France.
He won a gold medal with Team USA at the 11th Pan American Maccabi Games in Buenos Aires, Argentina, in 2008.
Warley, an original Wizard, was the starting kicker for a Virginia Tech football program that was a national contender during his time in Blacksburg.