They are currently members of the Southern Amateur League Senior Division 2 and play at the Paulin Ground in Winchmore Hill.

[1] After playing friendlies for a year, the club joined the Middlesex County Amateur League.

They won the league at the first attempt, also winning the Middlesex County Charity Cup.

After being joint winners of the AFA Senior Cup in 1952–53, the club were Division One champions again in 1955–56.

[2] Winchmore Hill won the AFA Senior Cup in 1959–60, but were relegated to Division Two at the end of the 1963–64 season.