The Silkworms' high water mark occurred from 2004 to 2008 when they recorded five consecutive playoff appearances.

The team hosted the 2004 NECBL All-Star Game and achieved a franchise best 24–17 record in the same season.

After the 2009 season, Silkworms owner Ed Slegeski sold the franchise to a team of partners led by Jonathan and Noah Crane.

[3] On April 30, the club announced the construction of a manual scoreboard patterned after the Green Monster at Fenway Park in Boston at the left-field fence.

[5] The Muskrats folded following the 2022 season after the league's governing board rejected the team's strategy to house players.