After The Andersons opened, many mall merchants reported higher sales, including Spencer Gifts, Kay-Bee Toys and Orange Julius.

[9] Woolworth also operated a restaurant adjacent to the store called the Harvest House Cafeteria from the time of the mall opening until 1994.

[11] Kahen and Kashani's plans for renovation never materialized, leading to the closure of the Elder-Beerman store and movie theater in late 2009.

[12][13] Mike Kohan, a New York real estate investor, bought the mall from Kahen in November 2009 and announced plans to add stores.

Kohan also attempted to sell the mall to Royale Property Management, a New Jersey concern, but the deal failed because it was contingent on the replacement of the structure's roof.

The county sought a permanent injunction to keep the mall closed, and the remaining tenants were told to leave by January 6, 2012.

In November 2012, The Andersons announced the closure of its Woodville location effective February 2013, leaving Sears as the only anchor.