In primary sources, he is mentioned as patriarch Shimun by several inscriptions dated from 1572 to 1577, while his additional name Yahballaha is recorded in a later report, submitted to Rome (1581) by metropolitan Eliya.
The same report describes recently deceased patriarch Yahballaha Shimun as an elderly hierarch, who was elected to the patriarchal see sometime after the death of Abdisho IV Maron (d. 1570), but did not seek confirmation from Rome, due to his advanced age.
[1][2][3] In spite of the lack of official confirmation from Rome, modern Chaldean Catholic Church considers him as a regular patriarch of the pro-Catholic line, but additionally holds that his predecessor was a certain Abraham.
[4] Modern scholars have proposed various solutions for complex questions related to this patriarch.
Some assumed that he was ordained bishop of Gazireh in 1556 by previous patriarch Abdisho IV,[5] but that assumption was not confirmed by later examination of primary sources.