As of 2023, the mall includes a number of prominent specialty retailers such as American Eagle Outfitters, H&M, Rue21, Francesca's, The Children's Place, and Victoria's Secret.

[20] In February 2018, Springettsbury Township officials announced that Penn National Gaming expressed interest in using the York Galleria area as a potential location for a casino.

[28] As of June 2019, Penn National was still waiting for confirmation of a date for its presentation, with the delay attributed to this first test of state gambling laws that had been changed in 2017, as well as to the prospect of a casino being the first that would be placed in a mall.

[29] In August 2019, Springettsbury Township supervisors voted to approve Penn National's redevelopment plans for the Hollywood Casino York.

[30] In October 2019, a Penn National spokesman estimated that the fourth quarter of 2020 was the target opening date; the mall owner also began work on the site in anticipation of control board approval.

[32] In March 2020, Penn National suspended construction due to the coronavirus pandemic; by August 2020, the opening date was pushed back to the second half of 2021.