Written by vocalist Nick Atkinson, guitarist Luke Potashnick and production duo Chris and Tony Griffiths, who co-produced the track with Mark Wallis and David Ruffy, it was featured on the band's 2005 self-titled debut album.

After its inclusion on Rooster in January 2005, "You're So Right for Me" was released as the third single from the album on 25 April 2005.

[1] It was backed with live recordings of the Cream song "Sunshine of Your Love" and the previously unreleased track "Bulletproof".

[3][4] In a review of the album for the website Gigwise, writer Alex Lai praised "You're So Right for Me" for "picking up the pace" after preceding track "To Die For", but concluded by claiming that it "isn't their best work".

[5] The music video for "You're So Right for Me" was directed by Jake Nava and first aired in the week of 11 April 2005.