The team compiled a 5–0–1 record and outscored opponents by a total of 111 to 32.
[1] The 1923 season marked a return to intercollegiate football for St. John's after an absence of 16 years.
The team was assembled on September 6 and trained for the following month before the first game on October 6.
[3][4] Right end Leo Prendergast was the team captain.
[5] The team played its home games at Ebbets Field in Brooklyn.