The 1958 Eisenhower Trophy took place 8–11 and 13 October on the Old Course in St Andrews, Scotland.

Australia won the Eisenhower Trophy, beating the United States by 222 to 224 in a playoff after both teams had finished on 918.

The playoff took place on Monday 13 October and followed the same format as the main event with the leading three scores counting.

For Australia, Doug Bachli scored 77, Bruce Devlin 72, Bob Stevens 75 and Peter Toogood 75 for a total of 222.

For the United States, Charles Coe scored 73, Bill Hyndman 78, Billy Joe Patton 75 and Bud Taylor 76 for a total of 224.