Following the success of this release, they played shows with bands such as Underoath, My Chemical Romance, Norma Jean, Haste the Day, Atreyu and It Dies Today.
After some member changes, the band wrote and recorded their second release on Indianola, an EP entitled Living in the Moment.
They toured the United States several times with bands such as The Banner, and then proceeded to write their second full-length release, Collapse.
Before entering the studio to record their third album, guitarist Jarrod Smith has also left the band, and was replaced by Adam Nordmeyer.
The album was recorded by producer Matt Goldman from Glow in the Dark Studios in Atlanta, Georgia.
On October 14, 2010, the original line-up of Across Five Aprils announced two reunion shows in Chattanooga, Tennessee and Marietta, Georgia.
The line-up included Drew Miller and Zak Towe (from A Tragedy in Progress), Brandon Mullins, Jarrod Smith and Josh Dycus.