In December 2022, he made his AEW television debut at Dynamite: Winter Is Coming, defeating Chris Jericho in an upset that drew comparisons to the May 17, 1993 bout between Razor Ramon and The Kid.
[15][18] On April 13, 2023 Andretti made his debut for AEW's sister promotion Ring of Honor, saving Darius Martin from an attack at the hands of Mike Bennett, causing the two men to form an alliance.
[15][23] On July 22, Martin and Andretti made their debut as a team on AEW Collision, losing to Bullet Club Gold (Jay White and Juice Robinson).
In December 2023, Andretti and Top Flight unsuccessfully challenged The Acclaimed and Billy Gunn for the AEW World Trios Championship.
In October 2024, Andretti and Top Flight unsuccessfully challenged the Blackpool Combat Club for the AEW World Trios Championship.
[27] On December 14 at the Winter is Coming special episode of Collision, Andretti and Rush defeated Top Flight, earning a future AEW World Tag Team Championship title shot.
[29] On January 18 at the Maximum Carnage special episode of Collision, Andretti and Rush attacked Top Flight, turning heel for the first time in his career.