[3] Moloney had been previously scouted by the Brisbane Lions, but her departure to Australia was delayed due to work commitments and injury.
[5][6] During the AFL Women's offseason, Moloney returned to Ireland to play for County Tipperary.
[5] Moloney would kick 21 goals during the 2024 AFL Women's season, to tie for the AFL Women's leading goalkicker award with Brisbane's Taylor Smith.
[7][8] She would finish second in Geelong's Best and Fairest count polling 98 votes behind winner Nina Morrison.
[9][10][11][12] At the 2024 AFL Women's Awards, she was selected to the 2024 AFL Women's All-Australian team in the forward line in recognition of her 2024 season,[13] and would sign a contract extension with Geelong until the end of the 2027 season.