She also played in the Women's National Basketball League (WNBL) for the Perth Lynx, Sydney Uni Flames and UC Capitals.

[1] Schwagmeyer transferred to Quincy University for the 2010–11 season and went on to be named the GLVC Player of the Year as a junior.

In April 2014, Schwagmeyer moved to Australia to play for the Kalamunda Eastern Suns in the State Basketball League (SBL).

She played just one game for Alexandria, scoring 30 points in 20 minutes, before accepting an offer from a first division team in Spain.

[2] She joined Cadí La Seu D'urgell, but she left the team in December 2014 to return home following the death of her sister.

[12] She averaged 20.6 points, 6.6 rebounds, 3.4 assists and 2.5 steals per game in 23 contests,[13] and was named the SBL's Most Valuable Player.

[32] She averaged 14 points, 4.59 rebounds, 1.95 assists and 1.14 steals in the 2018–19 season, and was selected in the WNBL Team of the Week in round eight.

Round eight featured her best game of the season, with 22 points, five rebounds, three assists, and two steals in a four-point win over the UC Capitals.

[33] She took a different approach to training in the off-season, shedding 10 kg to enter her second full WNBL season looking to play lighter.

[38][39] For the season, she earned WNBL Sixth Woman of the Year honors after averaging 15.3 points, 5.6 rebounds and 1.9 assists per game with predominately a bench role.

[42] In June 2024, Schwagmeyer was named head coach of the John Wood Community College women's basketball team.

[2] Following the death of her sister, Schwagmeyer remained in the United States throughout 2015 and served as an assistant coach for the Hannibal–LaGrange University women's basketball team while also working at the Quincy YMCA.

[50] In July 2019, Schwagmeyer married long-time boyfriend and fellow basketball player Courtney Belger.