All Things New (All Things New album)

"[9] At Worship Leader, Andre Hunter seconded that with writing that the release has "heartfelt, relatable lyrics and conversational quality—with plenty of scriptural ties—translate life with God into accessible reality.

"[6] However, Christian Music Zine's Joshua Andre felt that "if the first half of the album is a 5/5 (and it is close to that), then the last 5 tracks are a step down just a bit.

"[10] In the thematic area, New Release Tuesday's Fine assessed that the album deals with "confusion, hope, healing and surrender are deeply embedded, and you'll find yourself as a listener both inspired to praise and encouraged to press deeper into God.

"[10] At Cross Rhythms, Curry touched on that the band does "indeed" have a "pop sound gives a lively and upbeat offering despite tackling some difficult subjects but always focusing on the One who can help us in our trials.

At CCM Magazine, Matt Conner felt that the release only cemented them as "a band destined for long-term success and broad spiritual impact.

"[7] At Indie Vision Music, Andre found that the album "is a great choice to listen to if you enjoy contemporary pop with a southern-style acoustic edge.