Writing for Allmusic, critic Mark Vanderhoff wrote of the album "... a collection of his own compositions and American standards, played in his signature rootsy, jaw-dropping style.

While Donohue's own pieces showcase his mastery of fingerpicked acoustic guitar... From start to finish, American Guitar offers top-notch performances that are impressive without being cerebral or sterile.

Indeed, a sense of playfulness and fun are present throughout.

What really sets Donohue apart from the pack is that he somehow conveys that he's enjoying himself as much as the listener.

"[1] All songs by Pat Donohue unless otherwise noted.