The marriage finally took place in Dresden on 16 January 1586, and she received 30,000 Thalers as a dowry, as well as the city of Römhild as her Wittum (Dower land).

Despite the letters which Anna wrote to her husband and her relatives asking for mercy, on 12 December the Schöppenstuhl (High Court Chamber) in Jena formally annulled her marriage and sentenced both lovers to beheading by sword.

Anna was sent firstly to Eisenach, then to Kahlenberg Castle, in 1596 to the former Sonnefeld Monastery and finally (1603) to the Veste Coburg, where she died in 1613, aged 45.

Ulrich of Lichtenstein died in prison twenty years later, on 8 December 1633, just three days after being granted his freedom.

In 1599 John Casimir contracted a second marriage with Anna's maternal first-cousin Margaret of Brunswick-Lüneburg;[3] to humiliate his first wife, he celebrated this occasion with the famous Coburg Taler: on the obverse showed a kissing couple with the inscription WIE KVSSEN SICH DIE ZWEY SO FEIN (A well kiss between two), while on the reverse, showed Anna dressed as a nun with the inscription: WER KVST MICH - ARMES NVNNELIN (who kiss you now, poor nun?