The club are currently members of the Wearside League Premier Division and play at Derwent Park.

[1] In 1947, they also applied to join the Football League, though due to geographical concerns, the vote was never held.

[1] The club also competed in the FA Trophy on three occasions between 1969 and 1976, but never progressed past the first qualifying round.

[1] In the early years of the club's existence, Annfield Plain fielded a number of players who went on to play professionally in the Football League.

Examples include John Keers, who was signed by Football League Third Division North side Nelson for a fee of £150 in 1926.