The house was owned by several important early families in the town, including two mayors and a state representative.

Marston owned a dry goods shop on Main Street in Fort Atkinson, Wisconsin, and operated a branch in nearby Cold Spring.

In 1871, due to his failing health, Martson moved in with his son, George Marston, in San Diego, California.

It stood that way until 1898, when Hoard added Queen Anne elements, including the bay windows, the veranda, the Porte-cochère, and the rounded pavilion.

[2] When the Merchants Avenue Historic District was recognized on June 13, 1986, the Hoard House was listed as a contributing property.