In 2005, the school moved to its current location and added a freshman academy and a construction-oriented magnet program.

In 2011, Kathleen Weigel was promoted from principal of the school to the new district position of Assistant Superintendent of Professional Growth.

[12] The students of the academy designed and built a house called the "Eagle's Nest" (after the school mascot) for charity in collaboration with the city of Delray Beach.

[13] On October 25, 2010, the Construction Academy broke ground on a new house called "Eagle's Nest 2".

The school fields teams in 43 sports including football, basketball, baseball, swimming, soccer, softball, tennis, golf, bowling, wrestling, volleyball, cross country, track and field, weightlifting, and flag football among others.

The Atlantic Boys' Baseball Team won the 13-7A District Championship against Dwyer on April 24, 2014.

Atlantic is home to the Eagle Battalion of the Army Junior Reserve Officer Training Corps.