After the departure of Kofahl, Toby Hitchcock, who had been friends with Lead singer Justin Rivers for many years, was asked to come and join the group.
In November 2009, the band performed at the opening of Mercy Ministries' new locations in Sacramento, California.
The group was not able to sustain itself financially throughout 2010 and though it hurt Justin, Jason & Toby very deeply, the boys decided to take a break from touring.
In April 2013, Justin Rivers competed in the blind auditions for a spot on NBC's The Voice: season four, and was selected to be a member of the team mentored by country singer Blake Shelton.
In 2010, they received Dove Award nominations for Country Album of the Year and Long Form Music Video for Live at Oak Tree.