Apart from Dupri and co-producer Manuel Seal, Jagged Edge also worked with Selasi, Tha Corna Boyz and Crackpot on the album.

[2] While many of So So Def's acts moved with the label to Arista, Jagged Edge along with rapper Bow Wow were forced to remain at Columbia since they were contractually bound to the company.

He concluded: "Listen, if you don’t already own a Jagged Edge album it's hard to believe Baby Makin' Project will be your first, but long time fans won't be disappointed.

"[6] AllMusic editor Andy Kellman found that "as a title, Baby Makin' Project doesn't really do much to indicate that there will be much of a difference between its content and that of Jagged Edge's past albums.

There's a slightly higher percentage of ballads and midtempo songs, but for the most part, this is exactly what one should expect from the group by now – not a masterpiece, but another strong addition to the catalog.

He felt that Baby Makin' Project was "full of lush, strenuously sung R&B – the sort of thing that brings to mind candles, oiled pecs and dripping sweat.