As such, classmates Christopher, Kade, Cora, and Nadya venture out to revive Sumi and in the process, save her future family in the world of Confection.

[1] In a starred review, Booklist's Erin Downey Howerton called Beneath the Sugar Sky "phenomenal" and highlighted the character of Cora as the story's "true standout", given "her keen sense of observation and quiet bravery".

Downey Howerton also discussed how "McGuire suggests entire universes in a few spare sentences," as well as how "the delightfully diverse cast of characters is similarly conjured".

[2] Publishers Weekly referred to the novel as "a lush, darkly whimsical adventure full of wonders" and indicated that "readers will be thrilled to see old friends and meet new ones in this scrumptious tale that emphasizes acceptance, kindness, and the enduring value of friendship.

"[3] AudioFile reviewed the audiobook, writing, "Michelle Dockrey's smooth narration invites listeners to jump into this third installment of the Wayward Children series".