The club reached its peak between 1976 and 1977 where it finished 2nd in the league and lost in the final of the BP Top 8 Cup against Orlando Pirates.
The Club was brought back to life in 2005 as Benoni Premier United but after only 2 seasons in the Premiership was sold to Thanda Royal Zulu.
To succeed Mickey invited local Doctors and businessmen to join forces and fund the club, the group elected Dr Harrison Motlana as the founding Chairman and Mickey as the Secretary[3] The deal was sanctioned by the NPSL and Benoni United prepared to rejoin the Professional Ranks, the club used 1972 date as the club founding date for the second iteration of Benoni United.
Premier United owner Dumisani Ndlovu purchases the status of Hellenic F.C moving the club from Cape Town to Benoni.
The Club is renamed Benoni Premier United and regains Top Flight Status the next season.
The Club uses sky blue, blue, gold, dark gold, and black colors as its home colours and has a rabbit with a ball depicted inside a circle, it uses Orange and black as away colours this was introduced during the sponsorship from Kwikot.