[10] While in high school, she won the 2003 Ohio Speech and Debate Association championship in Humorous Interpretation.
[12] Stelling resided and worked in Chicago for five years until 2012, when she re-located to Los Angeles after releasing her first comedy album, Sweet Beth.
Stelling tours stand-up comedy clubs, colleges and festivals; guest starred on the Amazon Prime Video series Red Oaks; and wrote for Crashing, an HBO series from Judd Apatow starring Pete Holmes.
[19] On August 20, 2020, her one-hour special Girl Daddy premiered on HBO Max, and in 2021, she had a recurring role on the new Peacock sitcom Rutherford Falls.
[22][23] Stelling posted images of her bruised limbs on Instagram, stating that they were photographs taken when the abuse took place.