The Indiana-Michigan Mennonite Conference chartered a high school on June 4, 1953, to be built in Goshen on land that had been "home to a Potawatomi tribe".

[11] In 2021 extensive sports renovations were begun, including new tennis courts, a new pavilion, upgraded concessions and restrooms, and a new soccer facility, with a field surrounded by a new track, bleachers, press box and scoreboard, as well as new LED lights.

[12] In 2007, BCS was barred from hosting sectional championships because of its refusal to play The Star-Spangled Banner at sporting events, as the lyrics are at odds with pacifist ideals of Mennonites.

[13] By the 2015 school year, the BCS board decided to play the national anthem at certain sporting events, but it was criticized by some in the community for yielding to considerations of home-field advantage, revenue, and the publicity of hosting championship series, to make the decision.

The following Indiana High School Athletic Association (IHSAA) sanctioned sports are offered:[16]