At CCM Magazine, Grace S. Aspinwall wrote that "Her voice is pure and flawless and each song is perfectly arranged", and noted that "Her songwriting has also strengthened, and she shows depth and maturity [...] most exemplified on the title track", which "Moments of pop work their way into this mostly-worship project.

"[1] Phil Thomson said that Laura Story "wrote or co-wrote the tracks with the kind of intense, vested interest which leaves you in no doubt about the provenance, also making you wonder how she knows you so well.

"[2] At Christianity Today, Kristin Garrett stated that "the tracks with less orchestration and more melodic piano lines more aptly illustrate Story's vocal and songwriting abilities.

"[7] At Alpha Omega News, Ken Wiegman noted that the release was an "amazing follow up to a stellar debut that simply rocketed Laura into center stage of CCM", and that the album was "every bit a heartfelt worship project that again be a blessing to many.

"[8] At Jesus Freak Hideout, Jen Rose highlighted that the album was a "worship record all the way, and for the most part, it doesn't deliver a new, unique style", and wrote that "Initial listens, especially to the first half of the album, might sound like a typical worship record and feel unremarkable, but time spent with Blessings lets her earnest, tender music unfold into something sweetly beautiful.