It was decided that they would build a new structure at the newly established village of Argyle Station, as it was halfway between the two existing schools.

A committee was drawn up to decide costs and to place tenders in the local newspapers for construction of a brick veneer, two-storey building.

The entire school yard was fenced with two entrance gates allowing for a "U-Shaped" dive way for the horse drawn vans.

The school was originally built with just two classrooms, with a tower (containing the staircase, trustees room and principals office).

This was done on purpose, so that a future addition would need only classroom facilities, the tower would become centralized to serve both halves of the school.

Shallow brick arches give the windows a slightly round top, local field stone and mortar are used in the foundation and basement.

In the north end of this multi purpose room were three doors, one leading outside to the back of the school and the other two were access to the tower component of the building.

In the late 1990s a committee of community members from the Argyle area began to seek historic designation for the school.